Sunday, 4 November 2012

Deconstruction analysis of a painting by Alan Lee


Alan Lee (20 August 1947) is an English book illustrator and movie conceptual designer.  He was born in Middlesex, England and studied at the Ealing School of Art. He has illustrated many fantasy books including several works of J.R.R. Tolkien: the centenary edition of The Lord of the Rings (1991), a 1995 edition of The Hobbit, and the first edition of Narn i Chîn Húrin: the tale of the children of Húrin (2007).  This meant he was perfectly suited to become one of the lead concept artists for Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings films alongside John Howe. Lee has also worked as a concept artist on films such as LegendErik the VikingKing Kong and the television mini-series Merlin.

Alan Lee works exclusively with fine art mediums and this particular piece of artwork entitled ‘Frodo and Gandalf’ was created using water colour paints. He painted it in 1991 to illustrate the reissued edition of The Lord of the Rings which celebrated the 100th anniversary of the birth of Tolkien.  Lee interpreted what Tolkien had written to create the painting; ‘He was smoking in silence, for Frodo was sitting still, deep in thought. Even in the light of morning he felt the dark shadow of the tidings that Gandalf had brought.'

The painting depicts Gandalf the wizard smoking a pipe by the fire in the Hobbit hole; Bag End with the hobbit Frodo Baggins sitting nearby deep in thought. The fire takes up a large portion of the foreground and some of the hobbit’s home can be seen in the background.
Lee uses a variety of art elements effectively to create such a captivating painting. He uses thin wispy lines to create the textured look of hair and the detail on clothes.  The figures he has depicted are lifelike and well proportioned, he has given them real character; the white flowing hair, the piercing eyes and the crooked nose makes Gandalf seem old and wise as you would  imagine a wizard to be.  Lee has minimised the empty space in the painting, the majority is taken up by the two characters, meaning the focus is on them and the gravity of their situation is fully expressed through their clearly visible facial expressions.

The textures in the painting are predominantly rough with the thick clothing material and textured stone and wood giving the painting a charmingly old fashion quality.  The colours are warm and complimentary of each other, giving the painting a cosy, inviting feel.  There is a fairly wide range of tones in the painting, from dark shadow towards the back of the room to the bright fire which illuminates the characters and adds to the warm, relaxed feeling the painting creates.  The white colour of the fire creates the illusion of heat and the glow that it casts onto the characters minimises the need for detail in the foreground and throws shadows across areas of the painting, adding to the intensity of the piece.

There is a real depth to Lee’s painting with the fire in the foreground, the characters in the mid ground and details of the house in the background.  This makes the painting seem more three dimensional and sets the scene perfectly.  The body language and facial expressions makes the characters seem still and silent, clearly deep in thought.  There is a real emphasis on the characters’ grave faces with the light illuminating them well.

The painting was intended to illustrate an edition of Lord of the Rings, so it therefore adheres to Tolkien’s incredible vision and makes his descriptions come alive.  Being an illustration, the painting is unlikely to have any hidden meanings or symbols.  The book belongs to the Fantasy genre, so Lee’s painting is in keeping with this, the setting and clothing emphasising the old fashioned feel that is common to fantasy books.From a viewer’s point of view I find the painting warm and comfortable to look at, however there appears to be an underlying sense of fear.  Regardless of the story behind the painting, it is very aesthetically pleasing. 

Alan Lee’s painting greatly appeals to me, both because I am a fan of the book the painting illustrates and because the painting is captivating in its own right.  I really like the sense of depth the painting has which makes it appear three dimensional and interesting to look at.  I also think the use of lighting is very strong; it adds a diversity of tone and makes it bold and eye-catching. When creating my own concept artwork I will try to mimic the emphasis on composition that Lee has displayed here as well as the high level of detail and realism.